Payroll diversion
Payroll diversion is a scam in which an attacker poses as an employee and asks HR or payroll to change the bank account that receives the employee's salary. The next paycheck goes to the attacker. Some attackers skip the email and change the details in the payroll portal with a stolen password.
Updated
Payroll diversion is a form of business email compromise. The FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) warned about it in a 2018 public service announcement on stolen payroll sign-ins used to redirect direct deposits.
How payroll diversion works
Payroll diversion works in one of two ways: a request sent by email, or a change made in the payroll portal.
- Pick an employee. The attacker takes a name and a role from public profiles.
- Find payroll. The attacker finds who handles pay, often a shared HR or payroll address.
- Ask for the change. A message in the employee's name asks to update direct deposit before the next pay run.
- Supply new details. The attacker gives an account it controls.
- Or use the portal. With a password taken by credential phishing, the attacker signs in as the employee, changes the account and blocks the alert that would warn the employee.
What payroll diversion looks like
A payroll diversion message is friendly and brief. In this fictional example, the sender uses Megan Park's name. The sender is not Megan.
From: Megan Park <megan.park@freemail.example>
To: payroll@trotta.io
Subject: Update my direct deposit
Hi, I changed banks and need my salary paid to the new
account before the next pay run. What do you need from me?
I cannot get into the payroll portal right now.Megan's work address ends in trotta.io. The request came from a free mailbox outside the company.
Signs of payroll diversion
| Sign | What it means |
|---|---|
| The request comes from a private address | The sender cannot use the employee's work mailbox. |
| The employee cannot use the portal or the form | The attacker has no sign-in, so it asks a human to make the change by hand. |
| The change must happen before the next pay run | A deadline discourages checking. |
| The new account is a prepaid card | The FBI notes that diverted pay often goes to a prepaid card. |
| The message arrives just before payroll closes | Timing limits the chance of a callback. |
| A portal change with no matching request | Someone else may be signed in as the employee. |
Why payroll diversion gets through ordinary filtering
Payroll diversion gets through ordinary filtering because the message is one harmless-looking paragraph. The message has no link, no attachment and often no bank details until HR replies.
The mail is authentic for the free mail service it came from, so SPF, DKIM and DMARC pass. Spam and malware filters, including those in Gmail and Outlook, see a routine note from an employee.
The loss is often noticed on payday, when the employee is not paid.
When an AI agent reads the mail
An AI agent that triages an HR or payroll mailbox can be the one a payroll diversion request fools. The agent sees a polite request that fits its job and a form it knows how to fill.
An agent that can write to the payroll system should never take a change of bank details from an email. The safe design has the agent point to the portal and leave the change to the signed-in employee and a human in payroll.
How to stop payroll diversion
Payroll diversion is stopped by refusing to change pay details on the strength of an email.
- Use the portal. Accept direct deposit changes in the payroll portal, behind a sign-in with a second factor.
- Confirm with the employee. Call or ask face to face, using contact details already on file.
- Notify the work address. Send a notice of every change to the employee's work mailbox.
- Review changes before each pay run. A second human checks every changed account.
- Watch sign-ins. The FBI advises monitoring payroll sign-ins outside normal business hours.
At the door, before delivery
A pre-delivery inbox screens the request before HR or an agent can read it. Trotta Mail checks whether the sender is who it claims to be (SPF, DKIM and DMARC, lookalike domains, first contact) and whether the contents show payment fraud. Dangerous mail is held for a human. Mail worth a second look is delivered with the caution attached.
A payroll inbox suits lockdown mode, which lets in your own organization and allow-listed senders that prove who they are. Everything else, a private address under an employee's name included, waits for a human.
An agent's API key cannot read held mail, release it or loosen the mode. See the security model.
No filter catches everything. A well-written request with no technical tell can still be delivered, which is why uncertain mail is held or flagged for a human, and why payroll confirms every change with the employee.
Questions
What is a direct deposit change scam?
A direct deposit change scam is a request, sent in an employee's name, to move that employee's salary to a new bank account. Payroll diversion is another name for the same scam.
Who do payroll diversion scams target?
The message goes to HR or payroll staff, or to an agent that works their mailbox. The employee whose name is used loses the paycheck.
How should HR verify a direct deposit change?
Confirm with the employee by phone or face to face, using details already on file, and make the change in the payroll portal. Never rely on a reply to the same email.
What should we do if a paycheck was diverted?
Call the bank that sent the payment at once and ask for a recall. Report it to the FBI at ic3.gov and reset the employee's payroll password.