Trotta Mail vs Proofpoint: where each fits, and a Proofpoint alternative for agent mail

Choose Proofpoint to protect many existing Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace mailboxes, with archiving, eDiscovery and a large threat intelligence program. Choose Trotta Mail when an AI agent needs its own inbox that screens mail before accepting it and decides what the agent can read, release and send. The two can run side by side.

Updated

Proofpoint protects mailboxes you already have, in front of Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace as a gateway, or beside Microsoft 365 through an API. Trotta Mail is the mailbox itself: it screens each message at its own door, and it gives AI agents inboxes of their own.

Checked against Proofpoint's public pages on November 20, 2026. Confirm anything that matters with Proofpoint.

Trotta Mail and Proofpoint side by side

Proofpoint Core Email ProtectionTrotta Mail
Built forProtecting Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace mailboxes against phishing, business email compromise and other evasive attacks.AI agents and humans, each with an inbox of their own. The guard is stricter for an agent.
When incoming mail is screenedGateway: inline, before delivery. API (Microsoft Graph, no MX change): after delivery, with automated remediation. Links again at click time.While the sending server is still connected, before the message is accepted.
What an agent can read while a verdict is pendingSet by the mailbox behind it. Not found in their public docs.Nothing pending: the verdict comes before a message is readable. A key reads the safe view: hidden text removed, instructions aimed at a model marked.
Held mail and human reviewNot described on the product page. Ask who can release a held message.Held outside the inbox. A human can release it. An agent's key cannot.
Outgoing checksOutbound protection for threats and sensitive data.Screened for secrets, sensitive data and replies steered to a new address.
Sign-in codes kept from agentsNot found in their public docs.Sealed from every API key in a human's mailbox.
Inboxes for agents, MCP and SDKsNo inbox for agents found in their public docs. Secure Agent Gateway, built on MCP, governs the data agents reach.One API call per inbox. REST API, MCP server, TypeScript SDK, webhooks.
Archiving and eDiscoveryProofpoint Archive, Discover and Supervision.Not a documented feature. An audit trail of account actions is on every plan.
IMAP and SMTP accessMail stays at your provider, with the access it gives.None. Browser, API, MCP or SDK.
Price and plansNot published on November 20, 2026. The page links to how to buy.Free: 2 inboxes, 1,000 emails a month. Developer, $20 a month: 5 inboxes, 5,000 emails, up to 3 own domains. Startup, $200 a month: 50 inboxes, 50,000 emails, 5 seats, up to 25 own domains. Enterprise: custom.

Where each one sits in the mail path

Proofpoint documents two deployments, usable together. As a gateway, it inspects messages inline and enforces policy before delivery. Through the Microsoft Graph API, it needs no MX change and detects and remediates after delivery.

Trotta Mail has one path. Attacks, known and new, are refused at the door or held outside the inbox for a human. Everything else is delivered with a verdict.

What Proofpoint documents for AI assistants

Proofpoint documents protection for AI assistants that read mail. A post dated September 23, 2025 describes hidden prompts in email aimed at assistants such as Microsoft Copilot and Google Gemini, and states that Proofpoint detects and blocks them before delivery.

That post gives Q4 2025 for extending its detection to AI exploits delivered by email. It does not say which deployments or plans include it, so ask.

Proofpoint also announced Secure Agent Gateway, built on the Model Context Protocol, for Q1 2026. It controls and monitors the sensitive data AI agents reach.

Trotta Mail handles the risk inside the mailbox. An agent reads a safe view, its key cannot release held mail, and its outgoing mail is screened for secrets.

Where Proofpoint is the better choice

  • Many human mailboxes you cannot move. Proofpoint protects Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace where they are.
  • Threat intelligence at scale. Proofpoint states its detection draws on thousands of threat campaigns.
  • Compliance around the mail. Archive keeps mail with retention, search, legal hold and audit trails. Discover adds eDiscovery; Supervision adds review of regulated communications.
  • Certifications. Proofpoint's certifications page lists independent security certifications and US federal authorization. Check each one's scope.
  • Mail clients. Mail stays at your provider. Trotta Mail has no IMAP or SMTP access.
  • Breadth. Proofpoint also covers domain fraud, account takeover and messaging.

Where Trotta Mail is the better choice

  • An AI agent needs its own inbox. One API call creates it.
  • Screening before acceptance. No message sits readable before its verdict.
  • The mailbox controls the agent. An agent's key cannot release held mail or read a human's sign-in codes.
  • Agents' outgoing mail is checked for secrets and for replies steered to a new address.
  • A published price. Free to start, and every check is on every plan.

No filter catches everything, Trotta Mail included. A reworded scam with no technical tell can still be delivered, which is why uncertain mail is held for a human.

Switching from Proofpoint

For agent mail, switching usually means adding Trotta Mail beside Proofpoint. Human mailboxes stay behind Proofpoint; agent inboxes go on a subdomain.

  1. Leave Proofpoint and your human mailboxes as they are.
  2. Create an inbox for each agent with one API call.
  3. On a paid plan, connect a subdomain such as agents.example.com by publishing five DNS records.
  4. Change each agent's address where it is registered, then remove its access to human mailboxes.

Proofpoint is a trademark of its owner. This page is Trotta Mail's own comparison, based on Proofpoint's public documentation as of November 20, 2026.

Questions

Is Trotta Mail a Proofpoint alternative?

For mail that AI agents read, yes: Trotta Mail is an inbox that screens each message before accepting it. For existing human mailboxes, Proofpoint protects them where they are, and the two can run side by side.

Does Proofpoint screen mail before delivery?

Its gateway deployment inspects mail inline, before delivery. Its API deployment for Microsoft 365 detects and remediates after delivery. Proofpoint documents both.

Does Proofpoint protect AI assistants from prompt injection by email?

In a post dated September 23, 2025, Proofpoint states that it detects and blocks hidden prompts aimed at AI assistants before delivery. Ask which deployments include it, then test with a sample message.

Can I keep Proofpoint and use Trotta Mail?

Yes. Keep Proofpoint in front of your human mailboxes and put agent inboxes on a subdomain whose MX record points at Trotta Mail.

Sources

Every check is on, on every plan. Free for two inboxes. No card.