Trotta Mail vs Primitive: a Primitive alternative for agents that read untrusted mail
Pick Primitive if you want metered pricing that covers very high volume, hosted code that runs on every email, or a Go SDK. Pick Trotta Mail if your agent reads mail from strangers: every message is screened before it is accepted, risky mail is held for a human, and outgoing mail is screened.
Updated
Primitive and Trotta Mail both give AI agents email over an API. Primitive is built as infrastructure: it receives, authenticates and stores mail, then hands it to your code. Trotta Mail is built as an inbox that decides first: it screens each message before accepting it.
Checked against Primitive's public docs, trust page and pricing page on November 20, 2026. Prices are as listed on their pricing page on 2026-11-20.
Side by side
| Trotta Mail | Primitive | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | AI agents and humans. Humans get a mailbox in the browser. | AI agents and developers. Mail reaches your webhook, a hosted Function or the REST API. |
| When incoming mail is screened | While the sending server is still connected, before the message is accepted. Known-malicious mail is refused at the door. | Their docs describe the flow as MX, then parse, authenticate and store, then delivery. Sender block lists and a spam threshold can reject mail; the docs do not say at which stage. |
| Prompt injection and phishing screening | On by default, on every plan, for every message. | Not found in their public docs. |
| What your agent receives | A verdict decided before the message is readable, and the safe view: hidden text removed, instructions aimed at a model marked. | Parsed mail with SPF, DKIM and DMARC results and, when it ran, a spam score. Their docs say to check sender_verified before acting on instructions in a reply. |
| Held mail and human review | Held outside the inbox and withheld from every API key. A human releases it. | Not found in their public docs. |
| Outgoing checks | Screened for secrets, sensitive data and replies steered to a new address. Optional human approval. | Recipient gates: a new account sends to addresses that already wrote in with authenticated mail. Content screening: not found in their public docs. |
| Sign-in codes kept from agents | Sealed from every API key in a human's mailbox. Parsed for the agent in its own inbox. | Not found in their public docs. |
| MCP and SDKs | MCP with an API key or OAuth sign-in. TypeScript and Python SDKs, REST, webhooks, live events. | Hosted MCP with OAuth; send tools ask before sending. TypeScript, Python and Go SDKs, and a CLI. |
| Own domains | Paid plans: up to 3 on Developer, 25 on Startup. | On every plan, including the free one. |
| IMAP and SMTP access | No. | Not found in their public docs. |
| Price to start | Free: 2 inboxes, 1,000 emails a month. | Developer: $0 a month with $5 of usage credit. |
| Plans as listed | Developer, $20 a month: 5 inboxes, 5,000 emails. Startup, $200 a month: 50 inboxes, 50,000 emails, 5 seats. Enterprise: custom. | Power, $13 a month with $13 of credit. Platinum, $299 a month with $299 of credit. Email in or out: $1 per 43,000. |
Where Primitive is the better choice
- Volume for little money. Primitive meters email at $1 per 43,000 messages in or out. Its machine-readable pricing page says the free plan's $5 credit alone covers about 215,000 inbound emails. Trotta Mail's plans are flat and much smaller.
- Code that runs on every email. Primitive hosts JavaScript Functions that run on each inbound message, plus Primitive Memories for state between runs. Trotta Mail has no hosted code.
- More languages and tools. A Go SDK beside TypeScript and Python, open source SDKs, scheduled and batch sends, and a public OpenAPI spec.
- Keeping an existing mailbox. Primitive's mail relay keeps Google Workspace as the mailbox and copies each message into Primitive.
- Own domains from day one. Custom domains are on Primitive's free plan. Trotta Mail's own domains start on Developer.
Where Trotta Mail is the better choice
Trotta Mail is the better choice when a model reads the mail. Primitive's search docs say to treat a reply as untrusted input when its sender is not verified, and its email rules docs say a handler should check each email a rule passes before acting on it. Trotta Mail does that check before the message is accepted.
- Screening is built in. Prompt injection, credential phishing, invoice fraud, lookalike domains, deceptive links and disguised programs are checked on every plan.
- A safe view for the model. Hidden text is removed, instructions aimed at a model are marked, and risky links are defanged before an agent sees them.
- A human decides on held mail. Dangerous mail waits outside the inbox, and an agent's key cannot read or release it.
- Outgoing mail is screened. A secret in a message an agent sends is refused, and each connection can ask before every email or send drafts only.
- One product for agents and humans. Humans get a browser mailbox with sign-in codes sealed from every key.
No filter catches everything, Trotta Mail included. A cleverly reworded scam with no technical tell can still be delivered, which is why uncertain mail is held for a human.
Switching from Primitive
Switching from Primitive moves the check from your handler to the inbox.
- Create the inbox with one call:
POST /v1/agents/signupwith no account, orPOST /v1/inboxeswith a key. - Point your webhook at Trotta Mail. Its requests follow the Standard Webhooks spec, so swap the signature check. Or use the event stream, a WebSocket, or
GET /v1/inboxes/{id}/wait. - Give the model
textfrom the safe view and act onverdict, instead of checking authentication results yourself. - Move hosted Function logic into your own service: Trotta Mail does not run your code.
- On a paid plan, connect your domain: one click at providers that support Domain Connect, or five DNS records.
curl "https://api.trotta.email/ v1/ inboxes/ inb_7Qh2mXc4/ wait?timeout=60" \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TROTTA_MAIL_API_KEY"Primitive is a trademark of its owner. This page is Trotta Mail's own comparison, based on Primitive's public documentation as of November 20, 2026.
Questions
Is Trotta Mail a Primitive alternative?
Yes, for agents that read mail from senders you do not control. Both give an agent email over an API with MCP and SDKs; Trotta Mail screens every message before accepting it, and Primitive's docs hand authentication results and a spam score to your code.
Does Primitive screen mail for prompt injection?
Not that its public docs say, as of November 20, 2026. They document SPF, DKIM and DMARC results, a spam score, sender filters, and advice to check a reply's verified sender before acting on it.
Which is cheaper, Primitive or Trotta Mail?
Primitive, at volume. It meters email at $1 per 43,000 messages with a free monthly credit. Trotta Mail charges flat plans, with every check on every plan.
Can Trotta Mail run code on each incoming email?
No. Trotta Mail sends a webhook, a live event, or answers a waiting call, and your own service runs the code.
Sources
- Primitive docs: Receiving mail
- Primitive docs: Endpoints, filters and deliveries
- Primitive docs: Webhook payload (auth and analysis)
- Primitive docs: Search, threads and conversations
- Primitive docs: Email rules
- Primitive docs: Sending mail
- Primitive docs: FAQ
- Primitive docs: MCP server and connectors
- Primitive docs: SDKs
- Primitive llms.txt (product summary, mail relay, Functions)
- Primitive trust and security
- Primitive pricing
- Primitive pricing, machine-readable (what the credit covers)
- Trotta Mail API summary for agents
- Trotta Mail docs: security model, webhooks, plans and limits