Trotta Mail vs Dead Simple Email: scanned and stored, or screened and held

Pick Dead Simple Email if you want many inboxes for little money, IMAP and SMTP, and an advisory injection score your own code acts on. Pick Trotta Mail if you want the inbox itself to act: risky mail held for a human, held mail withheld from every API key, and outgoing mail screened.

Updated

Dead Simple Email and Trotta Mail both scan inbound mail for prompt injection. The difference is what happens next. Dead Simple Email's docs state its scanner is advisory: every message is stored and every webhook fires. Trotta Mail holds dangerous mail outside the inbox, where an agent's key cannot read it.

Checked against Dead Simple Email's public site, docs and llms.txt on November 20, 2026. Prices are as listed on their pricing section on 2026-11-20.

Side by side

Trotta MailDead Simple Email
Built forAI agents and humans. Humans get a mailbox in the browser.AI agents and automation, with a web dashboard.
When incoming mail is screenedWhile the sending server is still connected, before the message is accepted. Known-malicious mail is refused at the door.Their docs state the scan runs after the message is parsed and before it is stored. Whether anything is refused during delivery is not stated.
What the scan coversPrompt injection in the body and in documents, phishing, spoofing, lookalike domains, deceptive links and disguised programs.Message text, by pattern. Their docs state attachments, image contents, link targets and the HTML source are not inspected.
What an agent can readThe verdict is decided before a message is readable. A key reads the safe view: hidden text removed, instructions aimed at a model marked.Every message, with injection_risk and injection_score on it. Their docs say a hard stop belongs in your handler or in guardrails.
Held mail and human reviewHeld outside the inbox and withheld from every API key. A human releases it.Their docs state the scanner does not block, hold or quarantine.
Outgoing checksScreened for secrets, sensitive data and replies steered to a new address. Optional human approval.Guardrails the API enforces: sends per hour, allowed and blocked domains, draft approval before a send, and whether a key may reply, forward or delete. Content scanning of outbound mail: not found in their public docs.
Sign-in codesSealed from every API key in a human's mailbox. Parsed for the agent in its own inbox.Parsed for the agent: one call returns the code or magic link. Keeping codes from a key: not found in their public docs.
MCP and SDKsMCP with an API key or OAuth sign-in. TypeScript and Python SDKs, REST, webhooks, live events.Hosted MCP with OAuth 2.1. Python and TypeScript SDKs and many framework guides.
Own domainsPaid plans: up to 3 on Developer, 25 on Startup.1 on Hobby, 5 on Pro, 25 on Scale.
IMAP and SMTP accessNo.Yes, on every inbox.
Price to startFree: 2 inboxes, 1,000 emails a month.Free: 5 inboxes, 5,000 emails a month.
Plans as listedDeveloper, $20 a month: 5 inboxes, 5,000 emails. Startup, $200 a month: 50 inboxes, 50,000 emails, 5 seats. Enterprise: custom.Hobby, $5: 15 inboxes, 15,000 emails. Pro, $29: 100 inboxes, 100,000 emails. Scale, $99: 500 inboxes, 500,000 emails.

Where Dead Simple Email is the better choice

  • Price per inbox. Dead Simple Email lists 100 inboxes and 100,000 emails for $29 a month. Trotta Mail lists 50 inboxes and 50,000 emails for $200.
  • IMAP and SMTP. Every Dead Simple Email inbox comes with IMAP and SMTP credentials. Trotta Mail has neither.
  • Pay per request. An agent can pay with no account or key: $1.00 per inbox, $0.01 per send, paid in USDC or, for a new inbox, by card. On Trotta Mail only a human can pay.
  • Breadth. A calendar on every inbox, a sign-in provider where the inbox is the identity, and text from CSV files as well as documents.
  • Your own rules. If you would rather score mail and decide in your own code, an advisory score with no holding does exactly that.

Where Trotta Mail is the better choice

Trotta Mail is the better choice when you want the inbox to stop an attack, not only to label it. An advisory score helps only if every path that reads mail checks it first: the webhook handler, the list call, the MCP tool and the IMAP client.

  • Held means withheld. A held message read with an API key carries withheld: true and nothing its sender wrote, on get, list, search, threads, events, webhooks and MCP.
  • More is read. Trotta Mail reads the text of PDF, Word, Excel, PowerPoint and OpenDocument files, including text formatted to be invisible, and checks links and attachments.
  • Outgoing mail is screened for content. A secret in a message an agent sends is refused, whatever the recipient.
  • Humans in the same product. A human's mailbox seals sign-in codes from every key, and an agent in it writes drafts for the human to send.

No filter catches everything, Trotta Mail included. A cleverly reworded scam with no technical tell can still be delivered, which is why uncertain mail is held for a human.

Switching from Dead Simple Email

Switching from Dead Simple Email means fewer checks in your own handler.

  1. Create the inbox with one call: POST /v1/agents/signup with no account, or POST /v1/inboxes with a key.
  2. Point your webhook, event stream or WebSocket at Trotta Mail, or call GET /v1/inboxes/{id}/wait. Add has_code=true to wait for a sign-in code.
  3. Replace checks on an injection score with checks on verdict.action. Held mail never reaches the agent, so there is nothing to filter out.
  4. Move any mail client that used IMAP to the browser mailbox, or to the API.
  5. On a paid plan, connect your domain: one click at providers that support Domain Connect, or five DNS records.

Dead Simple Email is a trademark of its owner. This page is Trotta Mail's own comparison, based on Dead Simple Email's public documentation as of November 20, 2026.

Questions

Is Trotta Mail a Dead Simple Email alternative?

Yes. Both give an agent its own inbox with an API, MCP and SDKs, and both scan for prompt injection. Trotta Mail holds dangerous mail for a human; Dead Simple Email scores it and delivers it.

Does Dead Simple Email block prompt injection?

Its docs say no. The scanner annotates each message with a risk level and score, and never blocks, holds or quarantines. A hard stop is left to your handler or to guardrails.

Which costs less?

Dead Simple Email, by a wide margin, as listed on November 20, 2026. Trotta Mail charges for screening that acts before delivery, on every plan.

Does Trotta Mail extract verification codes?

Yes, in an agent's own inbox. Codes appear in extracted.codes, and a waiting call can return the next message that carries one. In a human's mailbox, codes are sealed from every key.

Sources

Every check is on, on every plan. Free for two inboxes. No card.